Foucault at 100: a public spat over "state racism" and a wave of posthumous publishing
As France marks the centenary of Michel Foucault's birth, an essayist's blunt attack on France-Inter has collided with a flurry of new editions of the philosopher's courses and writings.
The occasion for the latest Foucault controversy was a radio appearance. On France-Inter, the essayist and former senior civil servant Raphaël Doan called the philosopher's work "d'une grande médiocrité intellectuelle," according to Bibliobs (Le Nouvel Obs). Doan pointed specifically to Foucault's 1976 course, in which the philosopher discusses the notion of "racisme d'Etat," arguing that Foucault "aplatit absolument toutes les subtilités" of the question. Bibliobs's own headline frames the dispute as a question still open: did Foucault, as Doan claims, simply get it wrong?
The clash lands in the middle of a much larger editorial moment. Foucault's centenary has brought a run of posthumous publications and re-examinations, chronicled at length by En attendant Nadeau. The site describes a newly complete edition of Foucault's writings on Iran — the "dossier iranien" that provoked controversy when he reported from Tehran in 1978 — calling it a "somme passionnante" that, the site notes, arrives at a moment when Iran is again at the centre of the news.
Courses revisited, courses republished
En attendant Nadeau also reviews the first volume of Gilles Deleuze's 1985-86 course on Foucault, delivered at the University of Vincennes shortly after the philosopher's death, which the site describes as a "formidable et déroutante expérience créatrice" rethinking what it means to know, around the distinction between what an era sees and what it says. A separate piece examines Foucault's 1966-68 Tunis lectures, published as La place de l'homme dans la pensée occidentale moderne, which the outlet says were hugely successful at the time but whose arguments it suggests are worth re-examining six decades on.
Behind all of this sits a practical question that En attendant Nadeau poses directly: how should Foucault be edited after his death? The centenary, the site notes, has generated a substantial wave of editorial activity, along with recurring debates over which unpublished or out-of-print texts should see print and how they should be presented.
Sources
This article was written from these reports.